Why Illegal Gambling Sites Are a Risk, UKGC Data Shows
New analysis from the Great Britain Gambling Commission suggests that illegal gambling sites are not pulling players away from licensed casinos so much as sitting quietly alongside them. In a report published on 28 October 2026, the regulator used open banking payment data to trace how a sample of consumers moved between licensed and unlicensed operators. The headline finding is blunt: 91% of people with repeated payments to suspected illegal sites were also gambling with licensed operators. For anyone deciding where to play, the detail underneath that number matters more than the number itself.
The study is one of the first times a regulator has used real banking transactions, rather than survey answers alone, to map the black market. That makes it worth a closer look, even with the caveats the Commission itself attached.
What the Gambling Commission found
The research, which used banking transaction analysis, drew on financial transaction data to spot payments flowing to operators the Commission suspected of serving British players without a licence. Within the dataset, it identified 3,426 transactions tied to suspected illegal operators, linked to 179 individuals.
Of the people who made repeated payments to those sites, 91% were also placing bets or deposits with licensed operators. Crucially, the regulator found no substantial drop in licensed gambling after a consumer first paid an illegal site. In other words, the black market appears to supplement licensed play rather than replace it. The data also showed illegal payments arriving in clusters, several in a short window, often close in time to licensed transactions.
Why illegal gambling sites carry more risk for players
The more important signal for players is about harm, not market share. Of the 146 individuals in the sample who had a recorded Problem Gambling Severity Index score, 45% scored 8 or higher, the threshold the Commission uses to flag problem gambling. Among consumers whose transactions were with licensed operators, the comparable figure was around 6%.
That gap is striking, but it needs careful reading. The Commission was clear that the dataset is not nationally representative, that it cannot measure the true size of the illegal market, and that the figures do not prove illegal sites cause the harm. People already gambling heavily may simply be more likely to seek out unlicensed sites once licensed ones apply checks or block them. The honest summary is that heavy use of illegal gambling sites and higher harm scores travel together, and the direction of cause is not settled.
What is not in doubt is what players give up on an unlicensed site. There is no guarantee of fair games, no access to the complaints route run by the regulator, no funding of treatment services, and no obligation to run the safer gambling tools that licensed casinos must offer. If a withdrawal is refused or an account is frozen, there is little a player can do.
What it means for choosing a safe casino
None of this is a reason to panic, but it is a reason to be deliberate. The clearest protection is still to play only at operators licensed for your market. In Great Britain that means a Gambling Commission licence, which brings deposit limits, self-exclusion through GamStop, identity checks and dispute resolution as standard. Our guide to safe online casinos explains how to confirm a licence before you deposit, and our responsible gambling hub covers the tools worth switching on from day one.
It is also worth understanding what a licence actually signals. Our overview of casino licences sets out the difference between major regulators, and players in Britain can compare vetted options through our UK casinos and casino reviews sections.
What it could mean for payments and verification
The study has a direct payments angle too. Despite the ban on using credit cards for gambling in Great Britain, the Commission still found credit card payments to illegal sites, 138 of them, around 4% of the transactions identified. That underlines a simple point: unlicensed operators ignore the payment rules designed to protect players, including the credit card ban and affordability checks.
The research also shows how useful open banking data is becoming to regulators. As payment-level monitoring improves, licensed operators are likely to keep tightening identity and source-of-funds checks at online casinos. That can feel like friction at withdrawal, but it is the same machinery that keeps a regulated account recoverable if something goes wrong.
What players should watch next
This is one report in a wider Commission programme on the illegal market, so expect more detail rather than a single verdict. Two threads are worth following. First, how the regulator handles the blind spots in this method, since open banking data misses cryptocurrency payments and some unlicensed operators entirely, which means the real picture of illegal play is almost certainly larger than any single dataset shows. Second, the tax backdrop: with online gaming duty already higher in 2026 and further betting duty changes scheduled for April 2027, some industry voices argue that squeezing licensed operators too hard risks pushing price-sensitive players toward the black market. That debate is contested, and players should treat both the industry and campaigner framings with some scepticism.
Betspin view
The useful takeaway is not the eye-catching 91%. It is that the people most exposed to harm are often the ones drifting between licensed and unlicensed sites, and that the unlicensed side strips away every protection that makes a bad night recoverable. Choosing a properly licensed casino will not make gambling risk-free, but it keeps the safety net, the complaints route and the self-exclusion tools in place. For most players, that is the single decision that matters most.
Related Blog posts